This is a popular holographic insert from the Molten Metal set, featuring a dramatic dunk action photo with heavy foil/holographic background, iridescent “Supernatural” branding, and rainbow-shifting effects. These cards were premium for the era but are highly sensitive to surface wear, fingerprints, haze, and scratches on the front and back.

Pop Report

Overall Grade 9: 1

Overall Grade 8.5: 1

This raw example shows moderate surface wear typical of Molten Metal holographics — visible scratches, smudges, and clouding/haze under light, especially on the dark background and foil areas. Corners and edges are relatively strong, but the foil limits higher grades. No major creases or structural damage.BGS Subgrades:

Crescent Vale Self-Graded Scores

Centering: The centering was near perfect and received a 9.5 subgrade.

Edges: The edges had light wear and scored an 8.5.

Corners: The corners had light wear and scored an 8.5.

Surface: I originally had the surface as a 9.5 and after Grok’s review, I updated my score to an 8.

Crescent Vale Self-Graded Overall Score: 8.5 NM-MINT+

Grok AI Scores

Centering: 8.5/10

Good overall balance, minor natural variance in the holographic layering.

Corners: 8.0/10

Mostly sharp with light whitening and softening visible on close inspection.

Edges: 7.5/10

Minor wear along the perimeter and foil borders, typical for the thin stock.

Surface: 6.0/10

Significant deductions for micro-scratches, fingerprints, haze, and scuffing across the holographic finish (clear in angled lighting). The central image holds up better than the background.

Grok AI Overall Grade Prediction: 7.0 (NM)

A mid-grade result driven primarily by the surface. Cleaner examples can reach 8–8.5, but true high grades are scarce due to the foil technology.

PSA Equivalent Grade Prediction: PSA 7 (NM)

PSA is strict on holographic surfaces. This card fits a solid 7; an 8 is possible with favorable lighting/inspection.Market & Population Reference: Raw copies in this condition trade in the $50–$150 range (higher for strong eye appeal).

Graded: PSA 8–9 examples often sell $150–$400+; PSA 10s reach $800–$2,000+. Low-pop Gem examples command big premiums.

Population is limited; the Supernatural inserts are desirable for Jordan collectors despite grading challenges.

Note Grok and I were vastly different in grading this card. It noted:

10-point holistic scale focused on visual impact and severity of imperfections:10 = Perfect under magnification — no marks at all.

9.5–9 = Virtually flawless to the naked eye; tiny marks only under strong light/magnification.

8.5–8 = Very light wear (faint micro-scratches, minor haze).

7.5–7 = Noticeable but still clean (light scratches, some haze).

6.5–6 = Moderate, visible wear that affects eye appeal (multiple scratches, fingerprints, clouding/haze on foil, scuffing).

Below 6 = Heavy/obvious damage.

I updated my scores and wanted to be transparent about the subgrades.

Please Note: This card is housed in a custom display slab for superior protection and presentation. While the label may include descriptive details, this is not a grade from a third-party professional service (such as PSA, BGS, or SGC). The card is being sold as Raw/Ungraded. Please review the high-resolution photos provided to make your own assessment of the card’s condition before bidding or purchasing.